Saw II
Written by Darren Lynn Bousman and Leigh Whannell
Directed by Darren Lynn Bousman
2005The continued success of the
Saw franchise completely mystifies me. I thought the original
Saw was just awful-- stupid, clumsily directed and with some of the worst acting you're ever likely to see in a film released by a major studio. But somehow, it caught on. There's probably a book in the works somewhere about the sociopolitical/economic/etc. factors that allowed
Saw to catch on the way it did. In any case, barely a year after the original's huge success, Lionsgate rushed out
Saw II. And shockingly, it's actually worth watching. The best part is that you don't necessarily have to have seen the first film to know what's going on in
Saw II, which is great because you really don't need to see it anyway.
Some backstory would be useful, I suppose.
Saw introduced the character of Jigsaw (Tobin Bell), a serial killer who "doesn't kill anyone" because he puts people in situations where they can choose to do some sort of horrible damage to themselves
or just die. Jigsaw's gimmick is that he's a cancer patient, dying of a frontal lobe brain tumor, and he puts people in these situations so that they'll learn to appreciate the life they have instead of throwing it away. You would think this would apply to pretty much any person on the street, but as the series progresses it seems more and more like vigilante justice (this is actually confirmed in
Saw V). That's really all you need to know going into
Saw II, although for anyone who watched the first one there are some references, mostly accompanied by tiresome exposition that explains everything anyway.
So
Saw II opens with a guy in a trap (a series hallmark) who-- surprise!-- doesn't make it out alive. Police investigate and Detective Eric Matthews (Donnie Wahlberg, looking appropriately gruff and sweaty) is called out by Jigsaw for some reason. Matthews and his former partner Kerry (Dina Meyer) have crossed paths with Jigsaw before, but now it seems Matthews is his new pet project. The action jumps ahead a few days when Matthews has a brainstorm and realizes where Jigsaw's hiding out. Matthews and Kerry take a SWAT team to the hideout and find Jigsaw sitting patiently waiting for them, but not before a few SWAT team officers die in one of his traps, which
makes him a murderer. Sigh.
Anyway, Jigsaw directs Matthews to a bank of video monitors and a ticking clock. The monitors show a group of people trapped in a room, among them Matthews' son Daniel (Erik Knudsen). Matthews and Daniel's last interaction had been a screaming fight, and now Jigsaw is putting Matthews to the test. The ticking clock is roughly how much time the people in the house have until the poison gas they're breathing kills them all. Throughout the house are needles with the antidote, but each needle is in an elaborate trap. There are enough to save everyone, but only if they can find them before their 2 hours runs out and they all die. Jigsaw informs Matthews that all he has to do is sit and listen and his son will be returned safely.
Once all the setup is out of the way and the people in the house are introduced,
Saw II rarely lets up. It does exactly what a sequel to this sort of film should do: it expands on the themes and ideas of the original in an interesting way. It also works as a clever update to the slasher franchises of the 1980s. You know most or all of these people are going to meet horrible ends, but the killer is in a warehouse miles away, letting all his victims take care of themselves. The traps are considerably more gruesome than those in the first film, and mostly a little more fair. For example, the guy in the barbed wire in the first movie didn't have a chance; the idiot in the furnace in this movie should have known better. You actually get the idea that these people can get out of the traps if they just think for two seconds, which (naturally) they almost never do.
Saw II also has a very clever take on the series' trademark playing with time that I won't spoil. Suffice it to say, it's the only instance in the series when this particular gimmick has been done effectively. The performances are still pretty bad, but they're nowhere near as comically maniacal as those in the first film, and the bigger cast of characters are much more engaging than the two annoying guys we're stuck with for almost the entirety of
Saw. Jigsaw is given a much more active role this time around, and this is actually the only film in the series in which he seems like a formidable villain and not just a voice on some tapes. Subsequent sequels in the series have devolved into pointless retconning, a sad trend that reaches its nadir (one would hope) with
Saw V. As a standalone film,
Saw II is the only one in the series that can stand on its own merits. Investing in the rest of the franchise is an exercise in frustration, but I would recommend
Saw II any day.